us.testseek.com  

 
 
Search:   
 

Home » Games » PC » The Sinking City



Working
Please wait...

  Expert reviews    

Reviews of The Sinking City

Testseek.com have collected 69 expert reviews of the The Sinking City and the average rating is 66%. Scroll down and see all reviews for The Sinking City.
 
(66%)
69 Reviews
Users
-
0 Reviews
66 0 100 69

The editors liked

  • Endearing
  • Sometimes charmingly old-fashioned spirit
  • Nice visuals
  • Complex casework
  • Genuinely rewarding
  • Greast setting/mythos
  • Striking world
  • Lack of handholding is refreshing
  • The mystery solving element of the game is highly satisfying if you can push through its flaws
  • Some interesting detective mechanics
  • Cool premise
  • Some surprising cases
  • A fantastically unique world that always uncovers new details
  • Learns from Forgwares' previous titles to create a fantastic P.I game
  • Doesn't give you quest markers
  • Great story which utilizes the Lovecraft lore extremely well
  • Oppressive atmosphere
  • Big town to explore
  • Excellent investigation mechanics
  • Almost complete lack of handholding
  • Excellent character and location design
  • Excellent worldbuilding
  • Exceptional investigation mechanics

The editors didn't like

  • Cluttered
  • Ungainly menus and systems
  • An inordinate number of gameplay mechanics
  • Not one of them interesting
  • Properly integrated
  • Or well-developed
  • Oversized open world with a drab aesthetic that captures none of the lurking menace of Lovecraft
  • Poor
  • Slow travel
  • Poor combat
  • Legwork becomes a chore
  • Sense of mystery and fear is lacking
  • Absolutely riddled with technical problems that can't be blamed on Cthulhu
  • Sometimes not entirely clear what you're supposed to be doing
  • There are only so many conversations with dead eyed NPCs I can take
  • Too many reused assets
  • Too much dull gunplay
  • City feels empty
  • Combat is a weak point with guns feeling more like toys
  • Enemy AI is poor
  • AI issues for NPCs and enemies
  • Some sidequests are way too simple
  • Combat feels way too clunky
  • Technical issues that lightly impact performance
  • Poor presentation
  • Technical nightmare
  • Tedious combat

Show Show

 

Reviews

page 3 of 7
Order by:
Score
 
  Published: 2019-06-25, Author: Malindy , review by: eurogamer.net

  • Abstract:  The Sinking City is Frogwares' latest, and it's the team behind The Adventure of Sherlock Holmes series - a series that's been running since 2002 - most ambitious title to date. It tries to apply the dev's brand of detective gameplay to a sprawling open w...

Read the full review »    
Google translate to English »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
-
 
  Published: 2019-06-25, Author: Jordan , review by: gamesradar.com

  • Beautifully realised world, Truly Lovecraftian characters and narrative
  • Dull, monotonous gameplay loop, Plenty of bugs and a general lack of polish, Lifeless combat
  • The Sinking City's engrossing premise is ultimately betrayed by counterintuitive systems and bleak monotony...

Read the full review »    
Google translate to English »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(50%)
 
  Published: 2019-06-25, Author: Dominic , review by: techadvisor.co.uk

  • Rough edges run through The Sinking City - both the city and the game itself - but in the case of the latter it's mostly down to over-ambition.There are a multitude of systems and ideas stitched together here and most of them aren't quite done justice, ra...

Read the full review »    
Google translate to English »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(70%)
 
  Published: 2019-06-25, Author: Rosh , review by: dailystar.co.uk

  • An imagaintive location that feels new, Thoughtful detective puzzles that don't hold your hand, Incredible atmosphere that really unnerves,
  • Combat is a bit flat, Racism is a bit much,
  • Reviewed on PCThe Sinking City has an incredible atmosphere that really grips the darkest parts of your mind. Oakmont feels hostile, unwelcoming and full of secrets, but the game makes it clear that it might cost more than just your life to find out wha...

Read the full review »    
Google translate to English »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(80%)
 
  Published: 2019-06-25, Author: Brad , review by: criticalhit.net

  • Abstract:  I think a lot of people misunderstand what makes HP Lovecraft unique amongst horror authors. In trying to adapt the man's fiction, many are often drawn to the more outwardly horrific factors such as the esoteric cults, the hideous creatures and the secret...

Read the full review »    
Google translate to English »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(70%)
 
  Published: 2019-06-30, Author: Angad , review by: gamingcentral.in

  • Great atmosphere, Interesting setting, Clever deduction system, Cool map navigation,
  • Performance issues, Janky gameplay

Read the full review »    
Google translate to English »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(85%)
 
  Published: 2019-06-26, Author: Angad , review by: gamingcentral.in

  • Great atmosphere, Interesting setting, Clever deduction system, Cool map navigation,
  • Performance issues, Janky gameplay

Read the full review »    
Google translate to English »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(85%)
 
  Published: 2019-06-26, Author: John , review by: ap.ign.com

  • The Sinking City's creation of a new Lovecraftian vision paired with compelling stories, exciting environments, and memorable characters make for one of the better Cthulhu lore games I've played. Its commitment to tastefully updating the storytelling meth...

Read the full review »    
Google translate to English »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(78%)
 
  Published: 2019-06-30, Author: Sergio , review by: tribecareview.es

  • He hecho un esfuerzo muy activo en disfrutar y sobre todo en maquillar los problemas de «The Sinking City». Durante toda mi partida he intentado convertir la IA pobre y los edificios repetidos en características jugables fruto de la capacidad sensorial al...

Read the full review »
 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(55%)
 
  Published: 2019-06-26, Author: David , review by: gameit.es

  • La forma de dejarnos investigar, una delicia si nos gusta la temática, Una nueva forma de introducirnos en los mitos de Cthulhu, La ciudad de Oakmont y todos sus habitantes, tienen vida propia, La banda sonora en especial y el sonido en general
  • El sistema de combate no funciona todo lo que debería, Problemas en la IA y algún que otro bug gráfico
  • Los mitos de Cthulhu están de moda últimamente en el mundo de los videojuegos, y es algo que nos llena de alegría porque sus juegos están demostrando estar a la altura. Este título de Frogwares nos ha metido de lleno en la piel de un investigador privado...

 
Was this review helpful?   
 
(80%)
    page 3 of 7 « Previous   1 2 3 4 5 6 7   Next »  
 
More popular products from the same category


Join our Consumer Panel!

  • Infuence products of the future
  • Up to 4$ per answer
TestSeek will regularly send you survey invites to your email, you choose if and when you participate.

Join now! » (opens in a new window)


×